Shadow of the Colossus: Comparison Trailer

Inscrit depuis 5436 Jours

A hard pass for me. Hard because i want to play a "true" remake of the game, but not in this fashion. Highly competent from the tech side from it, as were those super skilled mod/ports of Ocarina of Time and Majora's Mask in Unreal Engine 4 from the tech side, but they just seem off. so very off. And this coming from a Dev house, it just stands like a sore thumb on the overall package. Even the face of the wandered is "why".

Blue point are hardcore porters, one of the best, but as content creators, to jump to asset design and worse, remastering old content faithfuly they don't seem to have that special skill in their workforce

The wanderer face, oh god. (again, at times... reeks of UE4 Mod)

https://i.pinimg.com/736x/db/f2/42/dbf24239aad35d9...

http://vacanerd.com.br/wp-content/uploads/2014/01/...

https://ibb.co/hxppEb

Funny thing, the game has more semblence with Ico than with SotC.

En réponse à

marker

Inscrit depuis 4602 Jours

Game looks really beautiful. I hope this game sells good this time. Honestly I am big fan of remake of the classic games. Wish Ubisoft would remake POP trilogy at least :((

En réponse à

This message and account have been deleted at the user's request

nostradamus

Inscrit depuis 5436 Jours

Posté par droezelke

Ok, second remake. Only more detail.

and half-assed detail. Most of the stuff is new like the grass and the cloud system, but then the agro and wanderer models still have thet "look" withy the complexity of meshes of a PS2 game. Even the way how the soft physics work could be true to the roots, but they are all messed up (agro's mane, wanderer's poncho) against the strong memories one had of the game b/c they were revolutionary at the time (like Icos) and here they just seem off, far away from "better".

En réponse à

Prower

Inscrit depuis 3970 Jours

Posté par nostradamus

A hard pass for me. Hard because i want to play a "true" remake of the game, but not in this fashion. Highly competent from the tech side from it, as were those super skilled mod/ports of Ocarina of Time and Majora's Mask in Unreal Engine 4 from the tech side, but they just seem off. so very off. And this coming from a Dev house, it just stands like a sore thumb on the overall package. Even the face of the wandered is "why".

Blue point are hardcore porters, one of the best, but as content creators, to jump to asset design and worse, remastering old content faithfuly they don't seem to have that special skill in their workforce

The wanderer face, oh god. (again, at times... reeks of UE4 Mod)

https://i.pinimg.com/736x/db/f2/42/dbf24239aad35d9...

http://vacanerd.com.br/wp-content/uploads/2014/01/...

https://ibb.co/hxppEb

Funny thing, the game has more semblence with Ico than with SotC.

Unfortunately I have to mostly agree. While the game still looks amazing, I think Bluepoint people are technical wizards (really, ICO in 1080p!) but I feel they could use more help in the artistic department.
Looking side-by-side the PS2 still feels bigger and more distant, while the PS3 remake mostly took all that away in name of resolution. The PS4 seems a lot better than the PS3 remake, anyway.

And yes, I thought that maybe it was just me, that I couldn't enjoy ICO AT ALL on PS3 because of some lack of "magic", I thought that was just me and my memory messing with my head. Then you look at The Last Guardian ad yes, all the magic is still there, even in 1080p, it's exactly as I rembered enjoying ICO and SOTC on PS2.

I'll buy this version, for sure, but I'm more than a little bummed out that they didn't find a way to keep all the magic intact from the PS2 version, it's such a pity.

En réponse à

[quote=nostradamus]A hard pass for me. Hard because i want to play a "true" remake of the game, but not in this fashion. Highly competent from the tech side from it, as were those super skilled mod/ports of Ocarina of Time and Majora's Mask in Unreal Engine 4 from the tech side, but they just seem off. so very off. And this coming from a Dev house, it just stands like a sore thumb on the overall package. Even the face of the wandered is "why".

Blue point are hardcore porters, one of the best, but as content creators, to jump to asset design and worse, remastering old content faithfuly they don't seem to have that special skill in their workforce

The wanderer face, oh god. (again, at times... reeks of UE4 Mod)

https://i.pinimg.com/736x/db/f2/42/dbf24239aad35d95de81a95196ddde3e--shadow-of-the-colossus-wander-videogames.jpg

http://vacanerd.com.br/wp-content/uploads/2014/01/SotC_Wander_Progress.jpg

https://ibb.co/hxppEb

Funny thing, the game has more semblence with Ico than with SotC.[/quote]

Unfortunately I have to mostly agree. While the game still looks amazing, I think Bluepoint people are technical wizards (really, ICO in 1080p!) but I feel they could use more help in the artistic department. 
Looking side-by-side the PS2 still feels bigger and more distant, while the PS3 remake mostly took all that away in name of resolution. The PS4 seems a lot better than the PS3 remake, anyway.

And yes, I thought that maybe it was just me, that I couldn't enjoy ICO AT ALL on PS3 because of some lack of "magic", I thought that was just me and my memory  messing with my head. Then you look at The Last Guardian ad yes, all the magic is still there, even in 1080p, it's exactly as I rembered enjoying ICO and SOTC on PS2.

I'll buy this version, for sure, but I'm more than a little bummed out that they didn't find a way to keep all the magic intact from the PS2 version, it's such a pity.

KORNdog

Inscrit depuis 6208 Jours

Looks so amazing. A world that actually looks worthy of exploration. Creatures with actual detail. Great fur tech. And they've built it from the ground up in aboit a 50th of the time it took team ico to make anything. I love how they've fleshed out the barron nothingness world of the original and made it look enticing to explore and not just a gap between colossi. And how they've fixed borked elements like arrow shooting from agro. Even the animations have had polish to make it all look more solid and less...limp.

Glad they havn't touched the controls for those who want to experience it as was, and glad they havn't fucked with the grip meter etc.

Cannot wait to buy this a third time.

En réponse à

INDIKA

Senua's Saga: Hellblade II

Paper Mario : La Porte Millénaire

Tales of Kenzera: ZAU en vidéo maison

GSY Preview Video : Paper Mario : La Porte Millénaire

GSY Review : Stellar Blade